GNU bug report logs - #47221
Guile not in native-inputs when it should

Previous Next

Full log

View this message in rfc822 format

From: Maxime Devos <maximedevos <at> telenet.be>
To: 47221 <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Subject: bug#47221: [PATCH v2]: Correct some inputs / native-inputs issues with guile
Date: Sat, 20 Mar 2021 22:45:47 +0100

[Message part 1 (text/plain, inline)]

Hi Guix,

The first patch ‘gnu: Explicitely pass the guile binary to wrap-script.’
does what it say what it does.  This is important for picking up the guile
binary for the architecture in --target instead of the guile from native-inputs.

(The unpatched & patched package definitions do not have a guile native-input,
so before this patch they wouldn't pick up a guile at all -- packages in inputs
do not contribute to the $PATH when cross-compiling.)

The second patch ‘gnu: Make guile packages cross-compilable when the fix is trivial.’
only touches guile libraries.  It adds guile to the native-inputs when required,
sometimes it adds guile to inputs and sometimes it copies propagated-inputs & inputs
to native-inputs when cross-compiling.  It also fixes some other cross-compilations
issues like autoconf being in inputs instead of native-inputs.

The second patch only touches gnu/packages/guile-xyz.scm; other packages are ignored.
Also ignored are: emacsy-minimal (there have been patches and/or bug reports lately)
guile-bash (retired project) and guile-studio (it is an Emacs package).

Suggested testing method:

(start shell script)
# BAD_PACKAGES: fails to compile
BAD_PACKAGES="guile2.0-commonmark guile3.0-ncurses-with-gpm guile-dbi guile2.2-pfds"

# OK_PACKAGES: compiles & cross-compiles
OK_PACKAGES="guildhall guile-daemon guile-dsv guile-filesystem guile2.0-filesystem guile2.2-filesystem guile-syntax-highlight guile2.2-
syntax-highlight guile-sjson guile-sparql guile-email guile-mastodon guile-parted guile2.2-parted guile-config guile-hall guile-wisp
guile-commonmark guile-stis-parser guile-persist guile-file-names guile-srfi-158 guile-semver jupyter-guile-kernel guile-ics srfi-64-
driver guile-websocket g-wrap guile-webutils guile-srfi-159 guile-torrent guile-irc guile-machine-code guile2.2-sjson guile2.2-dsv
guile2.2-email guile2.2-config guile2.2-hall guile2.2-ics guile2.2-wisp guile2.2-commonmark guile2.2-semver guile2.2-webutils guile-redis
guile2.2-redis guile2.0-redis guile-irregex guile2.0-irregex guile2.2-irregex mcron guile2.2-mcron guile-srfi-89 guile-srfi-145 guile-
srfi-180 guile-jpeg guile-hashing guile2.2-hashing guile-packrat guile-ac-d-bus guile-lens guile2.2-lens guile-rdf guile-jsonld guile-
struct-pack guile-laesare guile-mkdir-p guile-jwt guile-r6rs-protobuf guile-shapefile schmutz guile-cbor guile-8sync guile-squee guile2.2-
squee guile-colorized guile2.2-colorized guile-pfds guile-prometheus guile-aa-tree guile-simple-zmq guile2.2-simple-zmq guile-debbugs
guile-email-latest guile-miniadapton guile-lib guile2.0-lib guile2.2-lib guile-minikanren guile2.0-minikanren guile2.2-minikanren python-
on-guile"

# NOT_CROSS_COMPILABLE: self-describing (compiles natively)
NOT_CROSS_COMPILABLE="guile-cv guile-gi guile-ncurses g-golf guile-picture-language guile-sly guile-aspell guile-fibers guile-sodium
guile-reader guile-udev haunt guile2.2-haunt guile2.0-haunt guile2.2-ncurses guile-ncurses-with-gpm guile-xosd artanis guile-xapian
guile2.2-xapian guile-newt guile2.2-newt guile2.2-reader guile-avahi guile2.0-pg guile-libyaml guile-eris guile-ffi-fftw "

make
# replace aarch64 with architecture of choice and maybe adjust -M and -c
./pre-inst-env guix build $OK_PACKAGES $NOT_CROSS_COMPILABLE -M6 -c1 --fallback
./pre-inst-env guix build $OK_PACKAGES -M6 -c1 --target=aarch64-linux-gnu --fallback
make as-derivation
(end shell script)

Greetings,
Maxime

[0001-gnu-Explicitely-pass-the-guile-binary-to-wrap-script.patch (text/x-patch, attachment)]

[0002-gnu-Make-guile-packages-cross-compilable-when-the-fi.patch (text/x-patch, attachment)]

[signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, inline)]

Previous Next

GNU bug tracking system
Copyright (C) 1999 Darren O. Benham, 1997,2003 nCipher Corporation Ltd, 1994-97 Ian Jackson.