GNU bug report logs - #8420
dirname

Previous Next

Full log

View this message in rfc822 format

From: Bjartur Thorlacius <svartman95 <at> gmail.com>
To: Michele Marigliano <m.marigliano <at> almavivaitalia.it>
Cc: 8420 <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Subject: bug#8420: dirname
Date: Mon, 4 Apr 2011 17:23:23 +0000

You should probably not be using $0, as it doesn't contain a pathname.

Nonetheless, I believe there's truly a bug.
Retyped from the manual for dirname 8.5:
SYNOPSIS
   dirname NAME
   dirname OPTION
While simple, this doesn't describe the GNU implementation, which is more like:
   dirname -- NAME
   dirname OPTION
where OPTION begins with a hyphen or two.
The '97 SUS 2 spec has the most simple synopsis:
   dirname string

GNU dirname 8.5 (and some earlier versions) and FreeBSD dirname as
shipped with an  OS X 10.4 fail to filter strings starting with an
ASCII hyphen-minus, followed by one or more characters. FreeBSD
dirname conformingly fails with exit code 1 (presumably EXIT_FAILURE)
in all cases except if argv[1] is "--", in which case both GNU and
FreeBSD dirname ignore it, and use argv[2] instead. As does GNU
dirname 8.5, except for the strings "--version" and "--help", in which
case it writes non-conforming user messages to stdout and exits
successfully.

Busybox 1.14 considers the string "--help" as invalid, and writes
usage message to stderr and exits unsuccessfully. It's conforms to all
aspects of the standard, but the definition of a valid pathname. It
fails uniformly in the undefined case of more than two arguments.

Henceforth, there's no portable way to invoke dirname, as GNU and
FreeBSD dirnames fail if invoked as per SUS (with GNU dirname
sometimes exiting successfully, to confuse matters further), and
busybox fails if invoked per GNU conventions.

Note bene that the former method has to be tried first as GNU dirname
may fail successfully.
dirname() {
   env dirname -- "$1" ||
   env dirname "$1"
}

------------
tl;dr dirname -bash should output a single dot followed by a newline.

Previous Next

GNU bug tracking system
Copyright (C) 1999 Darren O. Benham, 1997,2003 nCipher Corporation Ltd, 1994-97 Ian Jackson.