GNU bug report logs - #32936
build-system/glib-or-gtk: Build 'in-source' by default.

Previous Next

To add a comment to this bug, you must first unarchive it, by sending
a message to control AT debbugs.gnu.org, with unarchive 32936 in the body.
You can then email your comments to 32936 AT debbugs.gnu.org in the normal way.

Toggle the display of automated, internal messages from the tracker.

Message #5 received at submit <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: Leo Famulari <leo <at> famulari.name>
To: guix-patches <at> gnu.org
Subject: build-system/glib-or-gtk: Build 'in-source' by default.
Date: Thu, 4 Oct 2018 17:08:20 -0400

[Message part 1 (text/plain, inline)]

As a followup to the discussion of glib-or-gtk-build-system building
out-of-source by default, and whether or not it should be the default,
I've pushed a wip-glib-or-gtk branch to Savannah.

It changes the glib-or-gtk-build-system to build "in-source" by default.

Can we schedule it for evaluation on either Hydra or Berlin, in order to
test it?

https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/guix.git/commit/?h=wip-glib-or-gtk

[signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, inline)]

Message #8 received at 32936 <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: ludo <at> gnu.org (Ludovic Courtès)
To: Leo Famulari <leo <at> famulari.name>
Cc: 32936 <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Subject: Re: [bug#32936] build-system/glib-or-gtk: Build 'in-source' by
 default.
Date: Fri, 05 Oct 2018 13:58:59 +0200

Hello!

Leo Famulari <leo <at> famulari.name> skribis:

> As a followup to the discussion of glib-or-gtk-build-system building
> out-of-source by default, and whether or not it should be the default,
> I've pushed a wip-glib-or-gtk branch to Savannah.
>
> It changes the glib-or-gtk-build-system to build "in-source" by default.

I’m all for it!

My REPL tells me 111 packages use this build system, which have 294
dependents (much less than I expected):

--8<---------------cut here---------------start------------->8---
scheme@(guile-user)> ,use(guix)
scheme@(guile-user)> ,use(gnu)
scheme@(guile-user)> ,use(guix build-system glib-or-gtk)
scheme@(guile-user)> ,use(srfi srfi-1)
scheme@(guile-user)> (define lst (fold-packages (lambda (p l)
						  (if (eq? (package-build-system p)
							   glib-or-gtk-build-system)
						      (cons p l)
						      l))
						'()))
scheme@(guile-user)> (length lst)
$12 = 111
scheme@(guile-user)> ,use(guix graph)
scheme@(guile-user)> ,use(guix monad-repl)
scheme@(guile-user)> ,use(guix scripts graph)
scheme@(guile-user)> ,run-in-store (node-back-edges %bag-node-type (fold-packages cons '()))
$13 = #<procedure 5a34f80 at guix/graph.scm:93:17 (node)>
scheme@(guile-user)> (length (node-transitive-edges lst $13))
$14 = 294
scheme@(guile-user)> (map package-full-name (node-transitive-edges lst $13))
$16 = ("xf86-input-libinput <at> 0.28.0" "libinput <at> 1.11.3" "spatialite-gui <at> 1.7.1" "lxde <at> 0.99.2" "pidgin-otr <at> 4.0.2" "engrampa <at> 1.18.2" "mate-screensaver <at> 1.18.1" "mate-settings-daemon <at> 1.18.1" "mate-netbook <at> 1.18.1" "mate-utils <at> 1.18.2" "ibus-libpinyin <at> 1.10.0" "ibus-anthy <at> 1.5.9" "mupen64plus-rsp-z64 <at> 2.0.0" "mupen64plus-video-z64 <at> 2.0.0" "mupen64plus-rsp-hle <at> 2.5" "mupen64plus-video-arachnoid <at> 2.0.0" "mupen64plus-core <at> 2.5" "mupen64plus-video-rice <at> 2.5" "scummvm <at> 2.0.0" "emulation-station <at> 2.0.1" "nestopia-ue <at> 1.48" "mupen64plus-input-sdl <at> 2.5" "mupen64plus-video-glide64 <at> 2.0.0" "mupen64plus-audio-sdl <at> 2.5" "mupen64plus-ui-console <at> 2.5" "mupen64plus-video-glide64mk2 <at> 2.5" "mrrescue <at> 1.02e" "love <at> 11.1" "quakespasm <at> 0.93.1" "wesnoth-server <at> 1.14.4" "fizmo <at> 0.8.5" "yamagi-quake2 <at> 7.10" "warzone2100 <at> 3.2.3" "vkquake <at> 1.00.0" "lugaru <at> 1.2" "openrct2 <at> 0.2.1" "gzdoom <at> 3.3.0" "xonotic <at> 0.8.2" "mygui <at> 3.2.2" "ogre <at> 1.10.11" "milkytracker <at> 1.02.00" "ocaml-tsdl <at> 0.9.1" "qtgamepad <at> 5.11.1" "aseba <at> 1.6.0-0.3b35de8" "enki <at> 2.0pre-0.afd2d8e" "frotz-sdl <at> 2.45pre" "sdl2-mixer <at> 2.0.2" "sdl2-ttf <at> 2.0.14" "ghc-sdl2-mixer <at> 1.1.0" "ghc-sdl2 <at> 2.4.1.0" "supertux <at> 0.5.1" "cataclysm-dda <at> 0.C-1.ad3b0c3" "starfighter <at> 1.7" "cdogs-sdl <at> 0.6.7" "crawl-tiles <at> 0.21.0" "raincat <at> 1.2.1" "ghc-sdl2-image <at> 2.0.0" "guile-chickadee <at> 0.3.0" "guile-sdl2 <at> 0.3.0" "sdl2-image <at> 2.0.3" "dolphin-emu <at> 5.0-3.5f0d825" "guile-gnunet <at> 0.0.383eac2" "gnunet <at> 0.10.1" "libextractor <at> 1.7" "virt-viewer <at> 7.0" "spice <at> 0.14.1" "spice-gtk <at> 0.35" "gst-libav <at> 1.14.2" "opencv <at> 3.4.3" "pianobar <at> 2016.06.02" "moc <at> 2.5.2" "mlt <at> 6.4.1" "mplayer <at> 1.3.0" "motion <at> 4.1.1" "handbrake <at> 0.10.5" "ffmpeg <at> 3.4.4" "synfigstudio <at> 1.2.0" "synfig <at> 1.2.0" "bs1770gain <at> 0.4.12" "retroarch <at> 1.7.5" "mgba <at> 0.6.3" "conkeror <at> 1.1.0" "geierlein <at> 0.9.13" "icecat <at> 60.2.0-gnu1" "openmw <at> 0.44.0" "openscenegraph <at> 3.6.3" "baloo <at> 5.49.0" "kfilemetadata <at> 5.49.0" "kodi <at> 18.0_alpha-8.ec16dbc" "alsa-plugins <at> 1.1.6" "qtox <at> 1.16.3" "clementine <at> 1.3.1-2.4619a4c" "chromaprint <at> 1.4.3" "mpd <at> 0.20.21" "cmus <at> 2.7.1" "demlo <at> 3.8-0.fe9ec4c" "vapoursynth <at> 37" "obs <at> 20.1.3" "curseradio <at> 0-1.1bd4bd0" "gnome-mpv <at> 0.15" "mpv <at> 0.29.1" "ffms2 <at> 2.23" "vlc <at> 3.0.4" "simplescreenrecorder <at> 0.3.11" "spacefm <at> 1.0.6" "ffmpegthumbnailer <at> 2.2.0" "you-get <at> 0.4.1077" "xpra <at> 2.3.4" "ffmpeg <at> 4.0.2" "python2-xsge <at> 2018.02.26" "python2-sge-pygame <at> 1.5.1" "impressive <at> 0.11.1" "python2-pygame <at> 1.9.3" "python-xsge <at> 2018.02.26" "retux <at> 1.3.5" "python-sge-pygame <at> 1.5.1" "bambam <at> 0.6" "roguebox-adventures <at> 2.2.1" "python-pygame <at> 1.9.3" "libsmpeg <at> 0.4.5" "blender <at> 2.79b" "vinagre <at> 3.22.0" "freerdp <at> 1.1-1.03ab683" "ffmpeg <at> 2.8.15" "python2-libvirt <at> 4.1.0" "python-libvirt <at> 4.1.0" "virt-manager <at> 1.5.1" "libvirt-glib <at> 1.0.0" "libvirt <at> 4.3.0" "qemu <at> 3.0.0" "lookingglass <at> a11" "wine-staging <at> 3.17" "wine64-staging <at> 3.17" "sdl2 <at> 2.0.8" "network-manager-openvpn <at> 1.8.0" "r-pore <at> 0.24" "r-svdialogs <at> 1.0.0" "mate-control-center <at> 1.18.2" "marco <at> 1.18.1" "zenity <at> 3.24.0" "devhelp <at> 3.26.0" "gnome-online-accounts <at> 3.26.2" "lollypop <at> 0.9.521" "yelp <at> 3.22.0" "gnucash <at> 3.0" "balsa <at> 2.5.3" "atril <at> 1.18.1" "surf <at> 2.0" "luakit <at> 2017.08.10" "wxwidgets-gtk2 <at> 3.1.0" "dvdstyler <at> 3.0.4" "wxsvg <at> 1.5.12" "wxwidgets <at> 3.1.0" "golly <at> 3.2" "sooperlooper <at> 1.7.3" "amule <at> 2.3.2" "aegisub <at> 3.2.2" "kicad <at> 5.0.0" "youtube-dl-gui <at> 0.3.8" "python2-wxpython <at> 3.0.2.0" "wxwidgets-gtk2 <at> 3.0.4" "audacity <at> 2.2.2" "elixir <at> 1.6.6" "erlang <at> 21.0.5" "filezilla <at> 3.37.1" "0ad <at> 0.0.23-alpha" "megaglest <at> 3.13.0" "freedink-dfarc <at> 3.14" "wxmaxima <at> 18.02.0" "aria-maestosa <at> 1.4.13" "hugin <at> 2016.2.0" "wxwidgets <at> 3.0.4" "webkitgtk <at> 2.20.5" "epiphany <at> 3.28.3.1" "eolie <at> 0.9.38" "webkitgtk <at> 2.22.2" "mate-user-guide <at> 1.18.0" "easytag <at> 2.4.3" "cheese <at> 3.28.0" "colord-gtk <at> 0.1.26" "simple-scan <at> 3.24.1" "sound-juicer <at> 3.24.0" "caja-extensions <at> 1.18.1" "gnome-clocks <at> 3.26.1" "eog <at> 3.26.2" "deja-dup <at> 34.3" "totem <at> 3.26.1" "rhythmbox <at> 3.4.2" "eom <at> 1.18.2" "pluma <at> 1.18.2" "libpeas <at> 1.22.0" "gnunet-gtk <at> 0.10.1" "tracker <at> 1.12.3" "gnome-session <at> 3.24.1" "gnome-disk-utility <at> 3.28.3" "gnome-settings-daemon <at> 3.24.3" "mutter <at> 3.24.4" "wmbattery <at> 2.51" "xfce4-power-manager <at> 1.4.3" "xfce4-session <at> 4.12.0" "xfce <at> 4.12.0" "xfce4-settings <at> 4.12.0" "gnome-tweak-tool <at> 3.26.4" "nautilus <at> 3.26.2" "gnome-control-center <at> 3.24.3" "libzapojit <at> 0.0.3" "shotwell <at> 0.28.4" "libgdata <at> 0.16.1" "gnome-calendar <at> 3.26.3" "folks <at> 0.11.2" "gnome-todo <at> 3.26.2" "evolution-data-server <at> 3.28.1" "gnome-maps <at> 3.26.2" "gfbgraph <at> 0.2.3" "gnome-shell <at> 3.24.3" "eog-plugins <at> 3.26.2" "gnome-default-applications <at> 0" "denemo <at> 2.1" "bluefish <at> 2.2.10" "mate <at> 1.18.0" "mate-media <at> 1.18.1" "mate-applets <at> 1.18.1" "gedit <at> 3.28.1" "gnome <at> 3.24.3" "emacs-cdlatex <at> 4.7" "emacs-org-edit-latex <at> 0.8.0" "emacs-auctex <at> 12.1.0" "emacspeak <at> 48.0" "emacs-company-quickhelp <at> 2.3.0" "emacs-pyim <at> 1.6.4" "emacs-pos-tip <at> 0.4.6" "emacs-org-web-tools <at> 1.0" "emacs-tide <at> 2.8.3.1" "emacs-helm-org-contacts <at> 20180707-1.0af703b" "emacs-mu4e-alert <at> 1.0" "emacs-academic-phrases <at> 0.1-1.0823ed8" "emacs-ansi <at> 0.4.1" "groovy-emacs-modes <at> 2.0" "emacs-tagedit <at> 1.4.0" "emacs-groovy-modes <at> 2.0" "emacs-spaceline <at> 2.0.1" "emacs-org2web <at> 0.9.1" "emacs-mustache <at> 0.23" "emacs-racket-mode <at> 0.0.2-2.b977873" "emacs-ag <at> 0.47" "emacs-hy-mode <at> 1.0.2" "emacs-all-the-icons <at> 3.2.0" "emacs-suggest <at> 0.4" "emacs-helm-bibtex <at> 2.0.0-1.8ed898f" "emacs-company-lua <at> 0.1-1.0be8122" "emacs-espuds <at> 0.3.3" "emacs-commander <at> 0.7.0" "emacs-minitest <at> 0.8.0-1.1aadb78" "emacs-string-inflection <at> 1.0.6" "emacs-ws-butler <at> 0.6" "emacs-dumb-jump <at> 0.5.2" "emacs-json-mode <at> 1.7.0" "emacs-json-reformat <at> 0.0.6" "emacs-cider <at> 0.15.1" "emacs-clojure-mode <at> 5.6.1" "emacs-slack <at> 0-4.d903954" "emacs-md4rd <at> 0.0.1-1.be0fc49" "emacs-request <at> 0.3.0" "emacs-butler <at> 0.2.4" "emacs-org-trello <at> 0.8.0" "emacs-zotxt <at> 20180518" "emacs-deferred <at> 0.5.1" "emacs-elpy <at> 1.24.0" "emacs-pyvenv <at> 1.11" "emacs-mocker <at> 0.3.1" "emacs-ert-runner <at> 0.7.0" "emacs-browse-at-remote <at> 0.10.0" "ert-runner <at> 0.7.0" "emacs-magit-todos <at> 1.1" "emacs-ob-ipython <at> 20150704.8807064693" "emacs-dired-sidebar <at> 0.0.1-0.06bd0d4" "emacs-dired-hacks <at> 0.0.1-1.eda6800" "emacs-pass <at> 1.7" "emacs-helm-pass <at> 20180416-1.ebcbef1" "emacs-password-store <at> 1.7.3" "emacs-helpful <at> 0.13" "emacs-elisp-refs <at> 1.3" "emacs-org-ref <at> 1.1.1-1.8c9b5d7" "emacs-f <at> 0.20.0" "emacs-s <at> 1.12.0" "emacs-picpocket <at> 20180610.1059" "emacs-helm-exwm <at> 20180703-2.56266f2" "emacs-exwm <at> 0.19" "emacs-xelb <at> 0.15" "emacs-exwm-x <at> 1.8.1" "emacs-mew <at> 6.7" "proof-general <at> 4.2" "hop <at> 3.1.0-pre2" "bigloo <at> 4.3b")
--8<---------------cut here---------------end--------------->8---

> Can we schedule it for evaluation on either Hydra or Berlin, in order to
> test it?
>
> https://git.savannah.gnu.org/cgit/guix.git/commit/?h=wip-glib-or-gtk

It should show up real soon here:

  https://berlin.guixsd.org/jobset/wip-glib-or-gtk

Thanks!

Ludo’.

Message #13 received at 32936-done <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: Leo Famulari <leo <at> famulari.name>
To: Ludovic Courtès <ludo <at> gnu.org>
Cc: 32936-done <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Subject: Re: [bug#32936] build-system/glib-or-gtk: Build 'in-source' by
 default.
Date: Sun, 7 Oct 2018 16:16:12 -0400

[Message part 1 (text/plain, inline)]

On Fri, Oct 05, 2018 at 01:58:59PM +0200, Ludovic Courtès wrote:
> It should show up real soon here:
> 
>   https://berlin.guixsd.org/jobset/wip-glib-or-gtk

Based on this, and my tests with a GNOME desktop system, I pushed this
change as 68afb9dccf91cc1a58b6db405befa176b191d809. Thanks for your
help!

[signature.asc (application/pgp-signature, inline)]

Previous Next

GNU bug tracking system
Copyright (C) 1999 Darren O. Benham, 1997,2003 nCipher Corporation Ltd, 1994-97 Ian Jackson.