GNU bug report logs - #26802
Single source file emacs packages get a ".el.el" extension

Previous Next

Full log

View this message in rfc822 format

From: Arun Isaac <arunisaac <at> systemreboot.net>
To: Alex Kost <alezost <at> gmail.com>
Cc: 26802 <at> debbugs.gnu.org
Subject: bug#26802: Single source file emacs packages get a ".el.el" extension
Date: Sat, 13 May 2017 22:06:05 +0530

I've pushed the other uncontroversial patches.

> It would be a linter only for *.el files, is that what you mean?  AFAIK
> we do not have such specific linters, but yeah, why not, I think it's a
> good idea.

No, it will be a linter for all packages, not just emacs packages.

The following is the current linter for checking source file names. I
have a couple of issues with it, in addition to the new linter feature I
am suggesting. Let me explain.

> (define (check-source-file-name package)
>   "Emit a warning if PACKAGE's origin has no meaningful file name."
>   (define (origin-file-name-valid? origin)
>     ;; Return #t if the source file name contains only a version or is #f;
>     ;; indicates that the origin needs a 'file-name' field.

Isn't this logic somehow backward? Should'nt a predicate called
`file-name-valid?' return #t if the file name is valid, and #f
otherwise?  This seems to be doing the opposite of that, returning #f if
the file name is valid, and #t otherwise.

>     (let ((file-name (origin-actual-file-name origin))
>           (version (package-version package)))
>       (and file-name
>            (not (or (string-prefix? version file-name)
>                     ;; Common in many projects is for the filename to start
>                     ;; with a "v" followed by the version,
>                     ;; e.g. "v3.2.0.tar.gz".
>                     (string-prefix? (string-append "v" version) file-name))))))

I think this check can be done by matching against a single regexp like
so:

(string-match (string-append "^v?" version) file-name)

In addition to this logic, we add an extra condition that makes sure the
version is some substring of the source file name, like so:

(string-match version file-name)

With this new check, single source file packages like
emacs-transpose-frame, etc. which did not have file-name fields would
have raised a lint warning.

>   (let ((origin (package-source package)))
>     (unless (or (not origin) (origin-file-name-valid? origin))
>       (emit-warning package
>                     (G_ "the source file name should contain the package name")
>                     'source))))

> P.S.  Could you please keep my email in Cc?  It would be easier to
> follow the discussion for me, thanks.

Sorry, I thought debbugs does some magic to send out mails to everybody
involved in a specific bug. Didn't realize it was only using Cc. Will
keep you in Cc for this and future mails.

Previous Next

GNU bug tracking system
Copyright (C) 1999 Darren O. Benham, 1997,2003 nCipher Corporation Ltd, 1994-97 Ian Jackson.