GNU bug report logs - #17467
24.3; locate-library returning spurious path

Previous Next

Full log

Message #38 received at 17467 <at> debbugs.gnu.org (full text, mbox):

From: Alex Kosorukoff <alex <at> 3form.com>
To: Stefan Monnier <monnier <at> iro.umontreal.ca>
Cc: 17467 <17467 <at> debbugs.gnu.org>
Subject: Re: bug#17467: 24.3; locate-library returning spurious path
Date: Sun, 11 May 2014 14:00:48 -0700

[Message part 1 (text/plain, inline)]

Stefan is right that the bug was there for a long time. I would like my
patch be compatible with older versions of emacs that don't have
string-suffix-p, so here is the revised version

# Bazaar merge directive format 2 (Bazaar 0.90)
# revision_id: alex <at> 3form.com-20140511205538-1asyz50g7d3y4lgw
# target_branch: :parent
# testament_sha1: d9ca6f57d0d8486d42ed77a739877a208a34f22e
# timestamp: 2014-05-11 13:55:53 -0700
# base_revision_id: monnier <at> iro.umontreal.ca-20140511034953-\
#   1mzcrftziwhrw9hl
#
# Begin patch
=== modified file 'lisp/subr.el'
--- lisp/subr.el        2014-04-09 01:48:07 +0000
+++ lisp/subr.el        2014-05-11 20:55:38 +0000
@@ -1857,10 +1857,14 @@
                                        load-path (get-load-suffixes)))
                     nil nil
                     t))
-  (let ((file (locate-file library
-                          (or path load-path)
-                          (append (unless nosuffix (get-load-suffixes))
-                                  load-file-rep-suffixes))))
+  (let ((file
+         (locate-file library
+                      (or path load-path)
+                      (unless (or nosuffix
+                                  (string-match "\\.elc?\\.gz\\'" library))
+                        (if (string-match "\\.elc?\\'" library)
+                            load-file-rep-suffixes
+                          (get-load-suffixes))))))
     (if interactive-call
        (if file
            (message "Library is file %s" (abbreviate-file-name file))

# Begin bundle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On Sun, May 11, 2014 at 1:45 PM, Alex Kosorukoff <alex <at> 3form.com> wrote:

> The issue is that locate-library returns spurious paths like ".*/tramp" or
> ".*xxx/tramp.gz" instead of returning a valid path to the library or nil if
> no matching path is found. This is both unexpected and incorrect given this
> function name and spec. It can cause user inconvenience or pose a
> security/privacy issue because a random file named "tramp" or "tramp.gz"
> placed in some directory of the load-path can be loaded instead of the
> standard library without user knowledge. This is why I would prefer to fix
> it.
>
> On Sun, May 11, 2014 at 12:50 PM, Stefan Monnier <monnier <at> iro.umontreal.ca
> > wrote:
>
>> > it should be just (".elc" ".elc.gz" ".el" ".el.gz") when nosuffix is
>> nil.
>>
>> Why?
>> Did you find some documentation indicating that this is how it should
>> work?
>> Or is it the behavior you'd prefer, and if so, can you explain why you'd
>> prefer that behavior?  Which concrete cases do you specifically care
>> about?
>>
>
> This was the first and simplest way to address the issue above. Eli
> Zaretskii made a valid point that it is not consistent with the way this
> function worked before and not the most convenient for the user. I agree
> with this, so I posted a patch that handles the cases he described, except
> that it addresses the issue above.
>
>>
>> The current behavior has been in use for *many* years and I expect that
>> a fair bit of code relies on it, so we'd need a really good reason to
>> change it.  Maybe we can accommodate your specific concrete cases in
>> some other way.
>>
>
> I understand that the bug was there for many years and many
> people implemented workarounds (I did). I don't think this is a valid
> reason to keep it though. We just need to be careful to make sure we don't
> introduce a regression while fixing it. Unit tests can help.
>
>
>>
>>
>>         Stefan
>>
>
>

[Message part 2 (text/html, inline)]

Previous Next

GNU bug tracking system
Copyright (C) 1999 Darren O. Benham, 1997,2003 nCipher Corporation Ltd, 1994-97 Ian Jackson.