The only change compared to your original should be that I load tm.el, activate tm-menu-mode, and use M-g key bindings instead of C-l and so on. With this, emacs -Q, I - open tty-1, tty-2, tty-3 in that order - then I click in the yellow frame - click on the Buffer menu in the menu-bar - click on *Messages*. Effect is a bit strange, some complaints about mouse bindings in the root frame, but no assertion. So I guess I'm missing something important. Any ideas?