Hi Alan,

Alan Mackenzie <acm@muc.de> writes:

> Hello, Arsen.
>
> Thanks for taking the trouble to raise this bug report last Wednesday.
>
> On Wed, Sep 11, 2024 at 20:52:15 +0200, Arsen Arsenović via CC-Mode-help wrote:
>> Package: cc-mode
>
>> <#secure method=pgpmime mode=sign>
>> Package: cc-mode
>
>> Hi again,
>
>> CC-mode appears to misindent enum and enum class:
>
>>   enum asda
>>     {
>>       asd
>>     };
>   
>>   enum class asasdas
>>     {
>>       asda
>>     };
>
> Yes.
>
>> These should be indented same as struct per
>> https://www.gnu.org/prep/standards/html_node/Formatting.html#index-enum-types_002c-formatting
>> (well, enum class isn't mentioned, but I see no reason to act different,
>> and GCC appears to do this, so it'd be convenient to keep struct-like
>> formatting).
>
> Yes.
>
>> When using C-c C-s, it appears that C and C++ mode do not even recognize
>> enum as a class-open, instead doing brace-list-open.
>
> Yes.  This bug has come up at least once before, on 19 February 2014, in a
> post to bug-cc-mode@gnu.org from Xue Fuqiao, Subject: CC Mode 5.32.5
> (C/l); The indentation of `enum' of the default `gnu' style is wrong?
> After having considered the matter for some time, I answered on 3 March
> 2014 as follows:
>
>     Even though there's a bug, it's been there for a _very_ long time
>     (since before 1997), such a long time that it would cause chaos if
>     it were to be fixed.  You can see many examples of this wrong enum
>     indentation all through the Emacs C source, and probably throughout
>     the entire GNU project.
>
>     If this bug were to be fixed, inconsistent (even if correct)
>     indentation would start creeping into thousands of files.  I think
>     it's best left as it is, unsatisfactory though that be.

As a data point here, the correct indentation is present all over GCC
(which has people using everything from vi over notepad++ to VScode, and
naturally, Emacs), but it is mixed up, presumably partially as a result
of this bug, so I'd prefer if the editor would DTRT OOTB.

Also, if there is intention to use automatic code formatting tools,
which some have expressed as desirable for the toolchain projects (and I
don't disagree - helps people who aren't using Emacs to get indent right
easily ;-) ), having incorrect indentation by the editor will be
burdensome, as it'd result in the editor and formatter fighting often.

And, given that nobody (AFAIK) uses Emacs to mass-reindent code, I
suspect the fallout of a fix will be gradual and silent.

As an alternative to fixing this bug so that the token is recognized as
a struct, we could have a new token for enum that does get indented
correctly OOTB and that affected projects adjust to avoid trouble in
their codebases.

> At the time, I opened a thread on emacs-devel, asking what other people
> thought about the bug (Date: 3 March 2014, Subject: The indentation of
> `enum' in the default `gnu' CC Mode style is wrong.)  Only one person
> responded, Paul Eggert, saying he would be in favour of fixing the bug.
>
> Ten years later, now, I still think that was the right decision to make,
> and that the bug should remain unfixed.  If you have nothing against it,
> I will close this bug as won't fix.
>
> Sorry about this.

No problem - thanks for responding :-)

Have a lovely day.
-- 
Arsen Arsenović